Secret Spots For The Best Pizza In New Haven

New Haven, Connecticut, might be famous for its prestigious university, but did you know it's also a pizza paradise? With a rich history of Italian immigrants bringing their culinary traditions, this city boasts some of the best pizza joints in the country. From the legendary pepperoni slices to unique local creations, New Haven's pizza scene offers something for every taste bud. Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, knowing where to find the best pizza can make your visit unforgettable. Ready to uncover the hidden gems that locals swear by? Let's dive into the secret spots that make New Haven a pizza lover's dream.

Secret Spots for the Best Pizza in New Haven

New Haven, Connecticut, is famous for its pizza. Known as "apizza" (pronounced ah-beets), this style is a must-try for any pizza lover. While some places are well-known, others are hidden gems. Let's uncover these secret spots.

Hidden Gems for Pizza Lovers

These lesser-known pizzerias offer some of the best slices in town. Perfect for those who want to avoid the crowds but still enjoy top-notch pizza.

1. Ernie's Pizzeria
   Tucked away in a quiet neighborhood, Ernie's Pizzeria has been serving delicious pies since 1971. Their thin crust and perfectly balanced sauce make it a local favorite.

2. Sally's Apizza
   Though not entirely a secret, Sally's often gets overshadowed by its famous neighbor, Pepe's. However, their coal-fired pies with a slightly charred crust are worth the visit.

3. Modern Apizza
   Located on State Street, Modern Apizza offers a cozy atmosphere and mouth-watering pizzas. Their Italian Bomb, loaded with meats and veggies, is a must-try.

Off-the-Beaten-Path Pizzerias

For those willing to venture a bit further, these pizzerias offer unique flavors and experiences.

4. BAR
   Known for its mashed potato pizza, BAR combines a brewery with a pizzeria. The industrial-chic setting adds to the overall experience.

5. Zuppardi's Apizza
   A short drive from New Haven, Zuppardi's in West Haven has been family-owned since 1934. Their clam pie rivals any in the area.

6. Grand Apizza
   With locations in both New Haven and North Haven, Grand Apizza offers a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas. Their white clam pizza is particularly popular.

Local Favorites Worth Trying

These spots might not be as hidden, but they are beloved by locals for a reason.

7. Pepe's Pizzeria Napoletana
   No list would be complete without mentioning Pepe's. Known for its white clam pizza, this iconic spot has been serving customers since 1925.

8. Da Legna
   Located on State Street, Da Legna offers wood-fired pizzas with creative toppings. Their truffle oil and mushroom pizza is a standout.

9. Abate Apizza & Seafood Restaurant
   Combining the best of both worlds, Abate offers delicious pizzas and fresh seafood. Their shrimp scampi pizza is a unique and tasty option.

Unique Pizza Experiences

For those looking for something different, these pizzerias offer unique twists on the classic pie.

10. Next Door
    This spot offers a variety of wood-fired pizzas with a modern twist. Their fig and prosciutto pizza is a delightful blend of sweet and savory.

11. One 6 Three
    Located in the East Rock neighborhood, One 6 Three offers creative pizzas in a cozy setting. Their BBQ chicken pizza is a crowd-pleaser.

12. Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina Napoletana
    Bringing a taste of Naples to New Haven, Zeneli offers authentic Neapolitan pizzas. Their Margherita pizza, with fresh mozzarella and basil, is a must-try.

Savoring New Haven's Pizza Scene

New Haven's pizza scene offers a variety of flavors and experiences. From the classic pepperoni at Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana to the unique white clam pie at Modern Apizza, there's something for everyone. Sally's Apizza brings a nostalgic touch with its coal-fired pies, while BAR adds a modern twist with its mashed potato pizza. Each spot has its own charm and specialty, making it worth exploring all. Whether you're a local or just visiting, these hidden gems promise a memorable culinary adventure. So grab a slice, enjoy the rich history, and taste the passion that goes into every pizza. New Haven truly is a pizza lover's paradise.