Header Notice

Winter is here! Check out the winter wonderlands at these 5 amazing winter destinations in Montana

Secret Amish Bakeries In Pennsylvania

Published:

by Ileana Stockwell

secret-amish-bakeries-in-pennsylvania

Have you ever wondered where to find the best Amish bakeries in Pennsylvania? Imagine biting into a warm, freshly baked pie or savoring a soft, buttery pretzel. These hidden gems offer a taste of tradition and simplicity that you won't find in commercial bakeries. Tucked away in the scenic countryside, these bakeries are run by Amish families who use recipes passed down through generations. From whoopie pies to shoofly pie, each treat is made with love and care. Ready to embark on a delicious adventure? Let's uncover the best spots to satisfy your sweet tooth and experience authentic Amish baking.

Secret Amish Bakeries in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania is home to a rich Amish heritage, and with it comes some of the most delightful hidden bakeries. These secret spots offer a taste of tradition and a slice of heaven. Ready to uncover these gems?

Hidden Gems in Lancaster County

Lancaster County is known for its rolling farmlands and Amish communities. Here, you'll find some of the best-kept secrets in the baking world.

  1. Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop
    Tucked away in the quaint village of Bird-in-Hand, this bake shop offers mouth-watering pies, fresh bread, and whoopie pies. The aroma alone will draw you in.

  2. Riehl’s Family Bakery
    Located on a picturesque farm, Riehl’s Family Bakery serves up homemade treats like sticky buns, apple dumplings, and shoofly pie. Their baked goods are made with love and tradition.

  3. Stoltzfus Bakery
    This bakery in Intercourse, PA, is famous for its soft pretzels and cinnamon rolls. The Stoltzfus family has been baking for generations, and their expertise shows in every bite.

Hidden Treasures in the Heart of Amish Country

Beyond Lancaster, other parts of Amish Country hold their own secrets. These bakeries are worth the trip.

  1. Kauffman’s Fruit Farm & Market
    Nestled in Bird-in-Hand, Kauffman’s offers not just fresh fruit but also delectable baked goods. Their apple cider donuts and fruit pies are a must-try.

  2. Beiler’s Bakery
    In the heart of the Reading Terminal Market in Philadelphia, Beiler’s Bakery brings Amish baking to the city. Their donuts, especially the maple bacon, are legendary.

  3. Julius Sturgis Pretzel Bakery
    Located in Lititz, this bakery is the oldest commercial pretzel bakery in America. Their hand-twisted pretzels are a crunchy delight.

Off-the-Beaten-Path Bakeries

For those willing to venture a bit further, these lesser-known bakeries offer unique and delicious experiences.

  1. Miller’s Bakery
    Situated in Ronks, Miller’s Bakery is a hidden gem offering fresh bread, pies, and cookies. Their pumpkin whoopie pies are a seasonal favorite.

  2. Glick’s Bake Shop
    In the small town of Leola, Glick’s Bake Shop serves up traditional Amish baked goods. Their sticky buns and cream-filled donuts are worth the trip.

  3. Zook’s Homemade Chicken Pies
    While not a traditional bakery, Zook’s in Ronks offers savory chicken pies that are a local favorite. Their pies are perfect for a hearty meal.

Sweet Surprises in Small Towns

Small towns across Pennsylvania hide some of the best Amish bakeries. These spots are perfect for a sweet escape.

  1. Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery
    Located in Ronks, Dutch Haven is famous for its shoo-fly pie. This bakery has been serving up this sweet treat since 1946.

  2. Sadie’s Bake Shop
    In the town of East Earl, Sadie’s Bake Shop offers a variety of baked goods, from cookies to pies. Their pecan pie is a standout.

  3. Amish Country Bakery
    Found in New Holland, this bakery offers a wide range of traditional Amish baked goods. Their bread and pastries are always fresh and delicious.

Hidden Gems Worth Visiting

Pennsylvania's secret Amish bakeries offer more than just delicious treats. They provide a glimpse into a simpler way of life. Visiting these hidden gems means enjoying fresh baked goods made with traditional recipes passed down through generations. From whoopie pies to shoofly pie, each bite tells a story of heritage and craftsmanship.

These bakeries are often family-run, adding a personal touch to every item. The Amish community takes pride in their work, ensuring high-quality products. Exploring these spots can be a delightful adventure, revealing unique flavors and warm hospitality.

Next time you're in Pennsylvania, make sure to seek out these hidden bakeries. You'll not only satisfy your sweet tooth but also experience a piece of Amish culture. It's a journey worth taking for anyone who loves good food and rich traditions.